Pre-order Today!
Scroll down to view full menu
Already know what to order? Click button below and jump straight to the order form, please allow up to 24 hours for response. -Thank you!
Full Menu below⬇️
- Pies listed below are current seasonal menu items
- Please feel free to fill out form for any questions or special requests
Ordering
Order Form at bottom of page
- Minimum of at least 2 days required
- Please make sure to include date for pre-order request
- Larger orders may require lead time of at least 1-2 weeks
- Delivery available starting at an additional $5 to your order (Hours for delivery are normally between 10am-12pm)
Payment Methods
We accept
- Zelle (under the email popnpies@gmail.com)
- Venmo (@popnpies)
- Cash
- Credit Card (will be emailed a payable invoice via QuickBooks payments)
PRE-ORDER MENU
10" pies (Certain flavors may not be available during the week of Thanksgiving and Christmas)
Apple Crumble
spiced apple filling baked in an all butter crust, topped with crumble
Blueberry Crumble
blueberry filling baked in an all butter crust, topped with crumble
Chocolate Peanut butter
light peanut butter filling inside an oreo crust, topped with dark chocolate ganache and chopped toasted peanuts
Banana Cream
layers of vanilla pastry cream and sliced bananas in an all graham crust, finished with whipped cream and nilla wafers
Chocolate Silk
light and creamy chocolate mousse filling in an oreo crust topped with vanilla whipped cream and oreo crumbs
Coconut Cream
coconut pastry cream with toasted shredded coconut in all butter crust topped with vanilla whipped cream
Lemon Meringue
lemon curd filling in all butter crust topped with toasted meringue
Classic Pumpkin
silky pumpkin custard infused with classic warm spices, baked in our all‑butter crust, finished with crushed candied pumpkin seeds
Bourbon Pecan
classic pecan pie with a touch of bourbon baked in an all butter crust
Egg Custard
egg based vanilla custard baked in an all butter pie shell
Salt & Maple
maple custard baked in an all butter crust finished with flaky sea salt
SAVORY PIES
10" Pies Comes fully baked with rewarming instructions **Not available during week of Thanksgiving and Christmas**
Chicken Potpie
Shredded roast chicken and vegetables cooked in together in cream sauce and baked inside an all butter pie crust
Beef Shepherd's Pie
Ground beef cooked with veggies and rich tomato sauce topped with mashed potatoes and baked together in an all butter pie crust
Spinach Bacon Quiche
Savory egg custard baked with bacon, onions, spinach and gruyere cheese in an all butter pie crust
gluten free and vegan options available as a custom order for an additional fee